'I don’t mind if I do' shows a polite interest without sounding overly eager. When offered a second helping of dessert at a friend's house: 'I don’t mind if I do, thank you!'
Pro Tip 2/3
Social Courtesy
This phrase can signal that you're accepting an offer more to be polite than from a strong desire. Neighbor: 'Would you like to try these homemade cookies?' You: 'I don’t mind if I do.'
Pro Tip 3/3
Light Humor
Sometimes used humorously to accept without any pretense of hesitation. At a party: 'We have extra cake, anybody?' You, with a smile: 'I don’t mind if I do!'