Pick/pull/tear somebody/something to pieces/shreds Definition 1 of 3Pro Tip 1/3Harsh Criticism Used when expressing very strong disapproval or pointing out faults in detail. The judges will tear her performance to shreds with their feedback. Pro Tip 2/3Metaphorical Use This phrase is usually metaphorical and doesn't involve physical tearing. Critics pulled the new movie to pieces for its plot holes. Pro Tip 3/3Negative Connotation It often carries a negative connotation and can sound overly aggressive. After the presentation, they tore his arguments to shreds.