Make your skin crawl
Definition 1 of 1
Pro Tip 1/3Emotional Intensity
The phrase conveys a strong emotional reaction, often related to fear or disgust. 
The way he stared at me made my skin crawl.
Pro Tip 2/3Not Literal
It's figurative speech. Your skin doesn't actually move, it expresses a strong inner feeling. 
Seeing the snake up close made her skin crawl.
Pro Tip 3/3Negative Contexts
It's used in negative situations. It's not suitable for positive or neutral experiences. 
The sight of all that trash made my skin crawl.