The action of authenticating always requires evidence to prove authenticity. The museum authenticated the ancient sculpture by carbon-dating it.
Pro Tip 2/3
Authority Matters
Usually, an expert or someone in authority authenticates items to give credibility. The signature was authenticated by a renowned handwriting analyst.
Pro Tip 3/3
Not Always Visible
Authentication can involve identifying things not immediately visible, like historical significance. He authenticated the coin's origin with records from the medieval period.